Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

22 Av 5764 - August 9, 2004 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family


BOOK REVIEW
Expecting Miracles: Finding Meaning and Spirituality in Pregnancy through Judaism

by Chana Weisberg
Published by Urim Publications
Reviewed by Judith Weil

Before I married, I rarely went to the doctor. I was a healthy young woman and my medical wellbeing was taken for granted. All of this changed when I was awaiting our first child. I was required to attend the clinic regularly and be examined, first monthly, then fortnightly, and then weekly. By the time it came to the final stages before the birth, I had two midwives standing next to me, taking a great interest in my wellbeing.

I never felt so important in my life.

And then, after our daughter was born, the two midwives, the women who had been my attendants, suddenly ignored me completely. They were totally focused on the new baby, and I was suddenly of less than marginal importance -- and I asked myself how it was that I hadn't realized that I had never really been important for myself, and it was the baby that counted.

Some two decades after this incident, one I recalled at all subsequent births, I was again with this same daughter in a delivery room, only this time it was she who was having the baby. As the spasm hit her, she gripped my hand tightly and said, "Sorry, Mummy, if I'm hurting you."

"Don't worry," I assured her, and then added, "Twenty years ago you hurt me much more, but you didn't say you were sorry.'

"If it's a boy, he will never say he is sorry," quipped the midwife.

It was a boy.

Every woman who has ever had a baby has stories to tell. Those I related above are just two of my many childbirth- related experiences. There are few experiences more precious than birth, child rearing and the feeling of being in partnership with Hashem in a miracle of creation.

My own personal anecdotes and reminiscences were brought to the forefront of my mind recently when I read "Expecting Miracles: Finding Meaning and Spirtuality in Pregnancy through Judaism." In this book, American-born Chana Weisberg, who now lives in Jerusalem, has collected birthing and parenting stories told by a large number and variety of mothers: older and younger, richer and poorer, Frum-from- birth and newly religious, spiritually oriented and matter-of- fact.

One mother said: "I was twenty-one when I first became a mother. It was exciting. I felt like I was finally starting real life."

Another said: "After you have children, you pray differently. You pray so hard that Hashem will bring you back from the birth safely so that you'll be able to take care of your children.'

The subjects that come up include infertility, adoption, abuse and depression. There are interviews with midwives, including Mrs. Rachel Chalkowski, who is universally known as `Bambi' and is certainly the best-know midwife in Israel, and arguably the most famous midwife in the world. Her approach in midwifery is that "the first priority should be safety -- and together with that should be the comfort of the woman and what she wants. But safety must come first, which is my opinion as well as the opinion of Jewish law."

Discussing Jewish laws that concern the birth process, she says, "When you are religious and a midwife, halocho plays a very important role. People are mistaken when they think that halocho only plays a role when a woman is giving birth on Shabbos. For example, to induce labor without a really valid medical reason is something that is forbidden according to a lot of poskim. A lot of women would like to be induced because it's erev Pesach, or because they are under pressure of a husband having to go abroad or their doctor has to leave. According to most of the rabbis, it is forbidden. People don't know that this is a halachic problem."

Working with a religious Jewish woman is not the same in many ways as working with other women, especially when it comes to calculating her due date. "There are many things like that that are different when you are working with religious people."

Although she will not compromise on safety, Bambi is in favor of women making their own decisions about how much pain they can handle. "Some people can take emotional pain. Some people can take physical pain. How can we compare people? How can we decide for others whether they should take drugs in childbirth? We are not their educators. We are here to serve them."

Bambi is the midwife whose quip regarding saying `sorry' was quoted above.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.