Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

12 Av 5765 - August 17, 2005 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

POPULAR EDITORIALS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Opinion & Comment
Complete Disengagement: Peaceful Solutions to the Mideast Crisis

by Rabbi Daniel Yaakov Travis

Bus Bombers

A number of years ago, at the start of the intifadah in Eretz Yisroel, there was a serious bus bombing on Taanis Esther. After this incident it was decided that we will no longer be like sitting ducks. The time had come to take affirmative action.

What was the decision? That Purim, soldiers were placed at every bus stop to prevent bombers from future acts of terrorism. A short time later, this idea was abandoned when it became clear that this plan was neither efficient nor effective.

In the midst of its implementation, I met one of the gedolei rosh yeshivos in Eretz Yisroel, and asked him for daas Torah on what had transpired. With fire in his eyes, he lambasted those who linked salvation to additional soldiers. "This will only aggravate the situation!" he shouted. Unfortunately, we have all seen the truth in his prophetic words.

In these auspicious times where everyone's eyes are on Eretz Yisroel, the question cannot be avoided: What can we do to protect ourselves from an enemy whose raison d'etre is to annihilate us? Are there any special measures that we can take at this time?

Turning to Prayer

"There is a Torah commandment to cry out to Hashem and sound trumpets, when the Jewish people experiences tzoros. As the Torah writes, `When you experience travail and call out to me with trumpets. This means that whenever you suffer from plague, pestilence or any other yissurim, you should call out to me and sound trumpet blasts" (Rambam, Taanis 1,1)

The Rambam understands that in addition to the mitzvah to turn to Hashem in prayer every day, there is a special mitzvah when the Jewish people are experiencing travail. From his words we learn that when faced with a national crisis that the correct course of action is tefilloh. If we follow his advice, the Rambam promises, ". . .this will cause the tzoroh to be removed" (Ibid. 1,2).

The Ramban is even more resolute about this course of action and writes that even though, to his opinion, there is no Torah commandment to pray every day, in times of national crisis there is a Torah obligation of tefilloh. During that time ". . . Our eyes and hearts should be turned towards Hashem alone, like the eyes of slaves to their masters" (Ramban, Sefer HaMitzvos 5).

When should a person daven for the removal of his personal or national tzoros? A person is permitted to add requests into the nusach of Shemoneh Esrei during the brochoh of Shema Koleinu (Shulchan Oruch 119,1). However halochoh lema'aseh it is better to recite them after he has completed the entire Shemoneh Esrei (Mishna Berurah 122,8).

In addition to personal prayers, tefillas rabbim, Tehillim said by many people, can have a major impact. How should this be done?

When davening in Yeshivas Kol Torah, HaRav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach made sure to announce the name of the person that the tefillos were being said for beforehand. He explained that the Tehillim were only considered tefillas rabbim if the mispallelim knew whom they were praying for (Halichos Shlomo 8,22).

During our shonoh rishonoh, my wife and I had an unbelievable number of tzoros. I spoke to many rabbonim about the situation, looking for direction for how to deal with such chaos. After speaking a number of times with HaRav Shlomo Brevda, he told me to come back tomorrow and we will have the answer to all of our problems.

The next day I came back, curious what the wondrous solution would be. He assured me that the only possible solution when one is undergoing such an extraordinary number of tzoros is tefilloh. He urged me to plead with Hashem for help at the end of the Shemoneh Esrei of Shacharis and Mincha, before taking three steps backward, and to conclude my petition with the following prayer:

"Even though I am not worthy to ask for such requests, nonetheless please do not leave me empty-handed before You, for I am pleading with You with a broken heart, and on Your tremendous kindness and Your incredible mercy I put all of my trust, may my heart rejoice in Your salvation."

In a short time our situation took a radical change for the better.

A Matter of Integrity

"G-d is close to all who call upon Him, to all who call upon Him with truth." (Tehillim 145,18). Although G-d hears the cries of all who turn to Him, He is only close to those who live lives of truth. Therefore people who maintain a life of honesty and integrity can hope to have their prayers answered (Kad HaKemach — Emunoh).

In this vein, during the Dor Hamabul, upon hearing that their lives were threatened by an impending flood, many individuals beseeched G-d to spare their lives. However because of their dishonesty, their prayers were not accepted.

In contrast, Iyov who guarded himself from the smallest monetary infringement, merited having his prayers answered (Shemos Rabboh 22:4. Maharil Diskin on Bereishis 6:13).

*

How careful must one be with other people's belongings? Although nearly every other mitzvah in the Torah can be set aside for the sake of saving a life, the offense of theft is so serious that even to save a life you are only permitted to take someone else's property on condition that you pay for it later. One is not allowed to steal even to save a life! Only if one intends to provide complete reimbursement afterwards, is stealing permitted in a life-threatening situation (Shulchan Oruch, Choshen Mishpat 359,4).

I recently visited a rov in Eretz Yisroel who is accepted as a godol by all camps, Sephardim, Chassidim, Ashkenazim, Chareidim, Mizrachi, and others. I discussed a complicated halachic shaila with him and afterwards, before leaving, I asked him about the government's Disengagement plan. He said, "And are you allowed to steal someone's house and property? Even to take a prutoh is a Torah prohibition!"

Trumpets and Shofars

"Whenever you have tzoros you should sound trumpets" (Bamidbar 10,9). As stated earlier, there is a mitzvah deOraisa to blow trumpets whenever the Jewish people experience tribulations. Hearing their piercing blasts helps focus one's concentration on the situation before him, in order to focus his mind on the prayer needed to get out of his travails (Sefer Hachinuch, Mitzva 384).

The poskim ask why don't we fulfill this mitzvah today (Magen Avrohom 576,1). Some explain that this mitzvah only applies in Eretz Yisroel when it is under Jewish jurisdiction. Even then, they add that a majority of the Jewish people must be suffering from the tribulation in order to obligate this mitzvah (Mishna Berurah 576,1).

HaRav Moshe Feinstein notes that the Rambam enumerates the mitzvah of sounding trumpets at a time of tribulation together with that of blowing them in the Beis Hamikdosh while offering korbonos (Mitzvos Aseih 59). The grouping of these two mitzvos together implies that they share the same halochos, and that the trumpets blown at a time of tzoroh must be the same as those sounded in the Mikdosh. Since we do not have such trumpets today, neither mitzva applies (Igros Moshe 1,169).

Some Sephardic communities still follow the Rambam's words. Since we do not have chatzotzros today, they have replaced trumpet blasts with those of the shofar. Therefore special prayer gatherings such a selichos are accompanied with shofar blasts (Heard from Rav Ba'adani).

Once there was a situation of tremendous tza'ar for the Jewish people in Eretz Yisroel. HaRav Tzvi Pesach Frank and the Beis Din of Yerushalayim ruled that trumpets should be sounded at the Kosel Hama'arovi in order to arouse Divine mercy and get out of this distressful situation (as cited in HaMa'ayan, Tammuz 5730).

Complete Disengagement

"What happens if a person's experiences distress and does not turn to Hashem in prayer nor blows shofar? Instead he says that his `tribulations are natural occurrences, and the way of the world.' These are words of cruelty for they cause the problems to increase.

"This is what the Torah means when it says, `You have gone with me bekeri (considered what transpired coincidental), therefore I will bring upon you anger of keri.' When I bring upon you tribulations so that you should return to me, if you say that these are chance I will amplify the fury of these attacks" (Rambam Taanis 1,3).

How will an increasing the intensity of the tribulations help us recognize that Hashem is behind what happened?

Certain incidents could be attributed to sociological and political norms. However at times a person or nation experiences such difficult circumstances that these events can no longer be explained as part of nature. Increasing their intensity is Hashem's way of saying: "Please, listen to the message that I am telling you. If you do not I will have to turn up the volume."

Tefilloh is a way of tuning in to what Hashem is relating to us through yissurim. Recognition that He is the Source of everything that Happens in our lives is the key to ending travail. As soon as we have understood this, there is no longer a need for the tribulations.

Our Sages tell us that in the end of days the final Redemption will come when we recognize that we have nothing to depend on other than Hashem (Sotah 49a). Anyone who takes a glance at what is happening in the world today recognizes that we are coming closer and closer to the fruition of their words. Up against an enemy that cannot be conquered, we can only turn our sight upwards and plead for Divine salvation.

As long as we consider ourselves connected to any philosophy or ideology other than Torah, we have not yet fathomed the depths of our Sages' words. Cutting off our ties from all "isms" other than Torah shows that we believe that the final day of salvation is totally in Hashem's hands (see Ramchal, Daas Tevunos). This is the real disengagement that lies before us.

As the Divine tapestry of events unrolls, let us get a headstart in recognizing what the final picture will look like, and turn to Hashem as the Single Source of Redemption.


All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.