Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

30 Tishrei 5766 - November 2, 2005 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

POPULAR EDITORIALS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family

Teenagers
by A. Ross, M.Ed

At a certain age, a person inevitably changes from a child to an adult. Some people find the transition smooth and uneventful, whereas others have a very difficult time. Besides physical changes, there are emotional and spiritual adjustments. The wish for privacy is particularly marked at this age, so frequently the growing child is not willing to confide his feelings to adults, least of all to his parents. As a result, he feels that nobody understands him. (We will call the teenager "he" in this article, just for convenience, while naturally the same applies to both sexes.) There are no hard and fast rules which will help to smooth the way for these growing children, (or for the adults who live with them), but if we understand some of the problems, and remember our own trials and tribulations at that age, life already seems easier.

A crucial factor in growing up is the show of independence, which frequently manifests itself as rebelliousness. The choice of clothes, the choice of music and the volume he plays it, or the way he decorates his bedroom may well give rise to conflict. "I don't want you to choose my clothes anymore; I will go with a friend or on my own," is a common declaration. It is futile to insist that the child wears clothes which conform to your taste.

If it is a matter of tzniyus, parents have to lay down the law, although a royal battle might ensue. However, if a child decides on a hairstyle which you positively dislike, or wears the most outrageous clothes, it is wise, although extremely difficult, to let it go. Furthermore, if he wants to live in chaos, that is his decision, but parents are entitled to insist that the disarray be limited to his room only. He will realize all too soon that disorder is a great disadvantage, although he will not do much about it. There will be no clean clothes for him to wear, as he has asked Mother to keep out of the room; so she was unable to pick up the accumulated shirts and socks from under the bed. There will be times of crisis when he cannot find his homework or anything else which he needs desperately. It is at times like these that a teenager might welcome an offer of help, instead of the "It's your own fault and I have warned you about it countless times," which he deserves. On the other hand, he might reject the offer and declare that he can manage.

Mood swings and irresponsible behavior are part and parcel of being a teenager. There are times when he urgently needs the support and empathy of parents, yet it is a very fine line between genuine concern and "interference," in the mind of this troubled young person. The teenager knows that he is not yet an adult, and although he might argue about them, he still needs firmly defined boundaries. He will argue because he disagrees with everything, for the sake of being contrary, or just because of an inner drive . . . for no particular reason. For all the show of bravado, most teenagers are extremely vulnerable and have very little self confidence. Once again, we will understand our children better, and be more tolerant of them if we remember that we went through the same difficult time, to a greater or lesser degree.

Parents are not permitted to hit a child who is over Bas Mitzva or Bar Mitzva, because this may cause him to hit back. The Rambam compares it to placing a stumbling block before the blind. Indeed, in theory, we do not need to educate children any more after this age, although we certainly need to censure them if we see them doing wrong. Slouching at the table, or bad table manners in general, might be extremely irritating to some people, but that is not "doing wrong."

When a child comes home from nursery school or from school, the mother will usually ask what sort of a day he had, what he did, what happened, and the child will tell some of his experiences. There are cases when introverted children do not divulge anything and it is like pulling teeth to get any information out of them, but this is rare. On the whole, children like to share the day's happenings.

When children refuse to talk, mothers are well advised to tell of their own experiences, to talk about what they did while he was in school. This often opens the floodgates and the child prattles away.

Suddenly, or gradually, the articulate, even garrulous child turns mono-syllabic. "How was your day?" Grunt. "Anything interesting happen at school?" Shrug. "What is upsetting you?" Nothing.

There is no point in saying, "Look I am still your mother, I am entitled to know what happened/ where you went/ what you did." It will only cause a rift. The child is not trying to tell you that you are not his mother: he is saying, in his silent way, that he finds it hard to discuss his private thoughts and feelings right now. Be patient and your darling boy or girl will return to you in good time.

Little children see what they see, hear what they hear, ask endless questions and come to their own conclusions, not always the right ones. Teenagers see things black or white, there are no grey areas. They may spend hours philosophizing and putting the world to rights with their peers, but not with their parents. They have no one to ask, as they feel they know everything better than the older generations. Grandparents, who were always so beloved, may now be seen as "past it," and not worth consulting. Not all phases come to all teenagers: as mentioned earlier, some sail through these difficult years without any problems.

The severity of the symptoms depends partly on the child"s nature and partly on the way he grew up. If parents have always listened to their children from an early age, and also talked to them and given them responsibility, in all likelihood these children will have a smooth transition from childhood to becoming adults. Some professionals, who deal with troubled children, recommend that before the onset of puberty, one parent or both should speak to the child and warn him of what is to come.

Parents are confronted in the course of their lives with numerous unexpected situations. However, they have at least ten years warning of the trials and tribulations which the teenager will experience. If they warn the child in advance that he will undergo emotional changes, and that he might get very angry about trivial matters, he might not remember the warning a couple of years later in the heat of the moment, but he will know that he is normal. Yeshiva boys in particular, if they are away from home, might go through a very bad patch. If they are secure in the knowledge that they have a good home, and above all that they are normal, this will help them weather the stormy years. In spite of this, they may prefer to confide in the Mashgiach as someone objective, rather than in a parent who they feel, is disappointed in them.

A boy might beg his mother not to come to visit him in Yeshiva. At this age, they are terribly aware of what "they" will say. Instead of being offended, the mother could ask him if he wants to meet her at some other place instead so that she could bring him some goodies. He might forgo the goodies or he might suggest some place away from the precincts of the yeshiva. Girls, too, go through a phase of being ashamed of their parents.

Some women do not buy clothes on their own, once they have teenage daughters. They are so anxious for their approval that the girls come with them to chose their clothes! These mothers have too little self confidence. They could easily say, "Look, this is the way I dress, and nobody thinks the worse of me for it. I let you choose your clothes, but you have to let me choose mine." Mothers are mothers and not sisters or friends, however much they would like a closer relationship with their growing daughters.

When a boy who is home for a few weeks for the holidays, says that he can't wait to get back to yeshiva, he is not insulting his doting mother who has made all his favorite dishes. He is expressing the idea that at home he is a member of the family, but in yeshiva he is himself . . . a person. A wise mother will bite her tongue and not call him an ungrateful wretch. These few years will pass and the children will be even closer to the parents than they were before. The same wisdom will serve her well when her daughter insists on going shopping with friends. Instead of the mother saying that she has bought her clothes since she was born and knows what suits her and where the best place is to shop, she should just tell her that she trusts her to get the right thing. If she feels that she is trusted, the girl will probably take the garment back if it is completely unsuitable.

Sometimes a kind word at the right time will be appreciated, even if the child does not react to it. For instance, your daughter is doing the dishes ungraciously, with a sour expression on her face, after you have told her firmly that it is her job today. When she has finished, you could say, "I noticed that you found it difficult to do the dishes today and I therefore appreciate your help all the more." She will not reply, but the words will be balm to her tormented spirit. Tell them about your own problems when you were that age. Again, there will be no response, but it shows empathy. Some parents tell the child, in private of course, during a calm moment, that it is his choice whether to spend so much energy on anger and frustration or whether to meet the challenge of being a teenager head on, and overcome it. Your words will find their mark sooner or later.

Acne does not improve the child's appearance and many teenagers are extremely conscious of their looks. When a small spot can be a major event, a face full of spots might be the end of the world. There are so many effective remedies to keep it under control, that mother can either obtain a recommended medication and put it on the child's bed, or she can advise him to go to a doctor or to a druggist. For girls there is always discreet makeup. Some lucky teenagers do not suffer from skin impurities.

While you are thinking that this child will never be normal again, slow subtle changes are taking place and your ugly duckling is gradually turning into a beautiful swan. If, for any reason, the child is not conforming at all and there is absolutely no communication between you, do not blame yourselves. Teenagers who have read all the articles on child care, may throw accusations at you such as, "If you had not done/said such and such when I was nine . . ." or "You should have let me . . . when I was twelve" will emphasize your inadequacy. Do not fall for this line.

We are all human, we have done our best, the way we knew it at the time. Even if you were over critical or expected too much of him, it is not too late to make amends. Show the child respect, listen to his opinions, however outrageous they might be, love him and love him, even if you get no response. Above all, DO NOT CRITICIZE HIM at this stage, however often you have to grit your teeth. If he will permit it, a pat on the shoulder or a short hug is a good expression of your affection, but not all people this age want physical contact. Discuss neutral subjects with him as you would with another adult. By the time they get married, these children will hopefully be loving members of the family again and will have forgotten most of their pontificating when they knew it all, and you knew nothing. May all our teenagers become well- balanced normal adults, anxious to keep Torah and mitzvos to follow in the tradition of their parents.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.