Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

12 Av 5761 - August 1, 2001 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NEWS
Degel Hatorah Central Committee Meets
by Betzalel Kahn

The Central Committee (Secretariat) of Degel HaTorah met in the movement's Bnei Brak office last week. The meeting was attended by Degel HaTorah representatives in the Knesset and in the municipal councils. At the meeting, the Knesset members presented reports on their activities in the Knesset and the Government since the founding of the current Coalition some five months ago. Productive, penetrating discussions were held on a broad gamut of issues. Tribute was also paid to the memory of the Ga'avad of Shearis Yisroel, HaRav Chaim Shaul Karelitz, zt"l.

The meeting was opened by HaRav Nosson Zochovsky, a member of the Degel HaTorah Rabbinical Committee. In his remarks about HaRav Karelitz, he cited the Ga'avad's loyalty and trustworthiness, as well as his total obedience to gedolei Yisroel. He said, "It is written; `Olas tomid ho'asuyoh beHar Sinai,' " meaning that a sacrifice that one offers daily must be as perfect as the original one offered on Har Sinai. The enthusiasm of people involved in communal affairs generally wanes as time goes by. However, this enthusiasm persevered throughout the Ga'avad's involvement in communal work, neither waning nor dissipating.

"The Ga'avad enthusiastically carried out all his tasks. He would run with the same fervor that characterized him thirty years ago. Communal activists grow weary at times. But they should regard each challenge as a new one, both in individual and communal matters. The Ga'avad also taught us to show deference to gedolei Yisroel. He would always seek the opinion of Maran the Rosh Hayeshiva, shlita, nullifying his own opinion in the face of Maran's, and then hasten to execute his bidding. He was unique in our times in the manner in which he nullified his opinion in favor of those of the gedolei Yisroel.

"The Ga'avad felt that bnei Torah should unite, and would always come to meetings for that purpose. We are obligated to continue to uphold his legacy," HaRav Zochovsky continued.

Chairman of the Secretariat, Deputy Education Minister MK Rabbi Avrohom Ravitz, also paid tribute to the Ga'avad, citing the phrase, "umiMidbor Matonoh," which Chazal explain homiletically to mean that whoever nullifies himself like a desert is given the Torah as a gift. "The Ga'avad was such a man. He was a shaliach derabonon. For him there was no left which is right, and right which is left. For him, there was a right which is right, and a left which is left. He would change his opinion the moment he heard that of the gedolei Yisroel. He was a man of truth, a man of mesiras nefesh, the emissary of gedolei Yisroel on various issues. His deeds were his teachings, and that is what remains for us."

Following these remarks, Rabbi Ravitz reviewed his activities in the Education Ministry, saying: "People think that when we are in power and hold positions, we can correct everything. If we manage to do less than that, they think that we have done nothing. In the past, we had many complaints about the Education Ministry. When I entered the Ministry I found that every single department was antisemitic, including the Torah Culture department. We were considered second class citizens. From the outset, this Ministry was built on the principle that there are 150 thousand (chareidi) children who are regularly ill- treated."

Rabbi Ravitz cited a wide variety of examples to indicate that the chareidi sector has been deprived for many years. "I plan to establish a professional investigation committee to ascertain whether the chareidi educational systems receive what they deserve. This has always been a corrupt, hostile ministry. Only lately, under the current Education Minister Limor Livnat -- someone who is interested in equality between the chareidi and non-chareidi sectors -- a favorable atmosphere has begun to prevail."

Rabbi Ravitz noted a number of rulings issued during the previous period of Yossi Sarid which have been canceled due to his recent efforts, following tremendous battles. He noted that in the upcoming school year, he will be in charge of classroom allocation to the chareidi educational system. "The chareidi system currently includes 150,000 students. There are also many Sephardi institutions that are requesting classrooms. In the Shas network there are another 15,000 students, and in the upcoming school year, we will divide the classrooms in an equitable manner. But we still have a long way to go to meet the tremendous demand that has accrued in the wake of discrimination over the years," Rabbi Ravitz concluded.

Secretary General of Degel HaTorah and Chairman of the Knesset Internal Affairs Committee, MK Rabbi Moshe Gafni, opened with a hesped for HaRav Chaim Shaul Karelitz. He then reviewed at length the coalition agreement with the Likud. "Sharon gave the Labor Party, Shas and the Russians everything they asked for. But he abandoned us and in this way was able to form his government quickly. After lengthy negotiations, we signed the agreement with him. We sought to pass a law on the issue of the draft of bnei yeshiva prior to the formation of the Government as a condition for our support, and it was passed. We asked that all issues pertaining to the religious status quo be anchored in legislation. We received positions in the Finance Committee and in the Education Ministry, with clearly defined, extensive authority, and Rabbi Ravitz was placed in charge of chareidi education in the Ministry. We received key positions in the Housing Ministry and the Interior Affairs Committee. In addition, Rabbi Ravitz serves as a member of the Ministerial Committee for Legislation.

"We are satisfied with Prime Minister Sharon and with his policy of restraint. His attitude toward us is an improvement on that of previous prime ministers. When occasional problems arise, he displays a positive attitude and tries to solve them. We have encountered no important problem that hasn't been solved. After a turbine was transported on Shabbos, Sharon issued an order prohibiting any further transfers. After Peres met with Arafat on Shabbos, instructions were issued to government ministers not to hold Shabbos meetings. Ariel Sharon knows that if we are dissatisfied and subsequently resign from the coalition, that will be the end of the Government."

Rabbi Gafni later spoke at length about the harsh reality encountered by Degel HaTorah representatives wherever they turn, and the fact that discrimination against the chareidi sector by government offices and local council heads increases daily. He attributed this fact to the countrywide success of the chareidi sector. "We feel threatened in the Education and Justice Ministries. The clerks are against us, as are the mayors, but nonetheless, we succeed. The mayors see that the chareidim go to new places, found communities, and as a result, they cause us more problems. This is an intolerable situation. We have a choice between not succeeding, so that they won't be afraid of us, or succeeding, and letting them fear us. Sarid left behind scorched earth in the Educational Ministry, and Rabbi Ravitz had to turn the Ministry clock back by two years. It's not an easy process."

Rabbi Gafni mentioned UTJ's struggle over the Jerusalem Religious Council. "At the directive of HaRav Yosef Sholom Eliashiv, we agreed that there should be a professional managerial committee. We have been proving all along that Degel HaTorah is the leading factor in all the battles of chareidi Jewry. As a result, we have become delegitimized throughout the State," he concluded.

Bnei Brak Mayor Rabbi Mordechai Karelitz noted that the Degel HaTorah representatives are struggling to preserve the status quo, and that it is important that the public know that this is a very difficult battle. Our needs have grown and there are no chareidi Jews in any government offices; thus no one who understands our needs. The situation is similar in the municipal councils, and our representatives must concern themselves with petty matters -- involvement which sometimes takes place at the expense of more important issues.

"Today, and in recent years, more than in the past, so many decisions by government ministries and municipal councils have been anti-religious. In our battles, we must reach out to broader sectors, so that they will feel at ease identifying with our message."

Jerusalem Deputy Mayor Rabbi Uri Lapoliansky noted that even if all members of the Jerusalem Municipality were chareidi, the municipal clerks would still find ways to circumvent us. "There is no doubt that there have been positive changes, and we feel that progress has been made, but change should take place not only with respect to possible activities, but also between the national and local governments. It is important to bring about stronger cooperation between the Knesset members and the various ministries at this time: a time when we have found willingness to hear and accept, a willingness resulting from connections that were made between various ministries and the Degel HaTorah representatives in the local councils. It is important to help each other, and to find solutions for the problems with which we all grapple."

Rabbi Mordechai Blau mentioned that Toda'a, the organization founded by Maran HaRav Eliezer Menachem Shach, shlita, is currently in difficult straits. "On erev Pesach we had to cancel the Toda'a youth activities, due to a lack of funds. In time for the summer, Rabbi Gafni convened an emergency meeting and we managed to conduct activities in various cities, with the help of the heads of the local councils and Degel HaTorah. Some Torah shiurim did not have to be closed down. However, the avreichim have received neither salaries nor reimbursement of travel expenses for an entire year." He called to those present at the meeting to rally to the aid of this important organization.

Rabbi Eliezer Greenbaum, a member of the Beit Shemesh City Council, briefly reviewed the situation in his city, noting that today there are 30,00 chareidim in Beit Shemesh, as opposed to 5000 a few years ago. "The chareidi educational system constitutes 50 percent of the city's overall education system, yet it has no significant political power," he said.

"The mayor, Danny Vaknin, is afraid that the city will become chareidi, and almost no chareidi educational institutions have received municipal subsidies. Nearly all of the chareidi educational systems are located in rented rooms, and in Ramat Beit Shemesh Alef, not one kindergarten has a permanent home. He gave two classrooms to the kindergarten classes of the Talmud Torah, but now he intends to abandon those classes. Since this phenomenon is likely to reoccur in other cities, Knesset members should consider Beit Shemesh as an important precedent. The MKs should give the Beit Shemesh affair their urgent attention, and if we succeed there, others will be apprehensive of us, too."

Rabbi Chaim Williger of Haifa urged that a day-long seminar be held for Degel HaTorah representatives throughout the country, where important issues would be clarified.

Rabbi Avrohom Feiner, a member of the Jerusalem Municipal Council, commended the fact that the [Jerusalem] educational institutions do receive what they deserve. He called for the inclusion of student allotments for the chareidi educational institutions in the basis of the state budget. He also discussed the shortage of classrooms in Jerusalem, noting that the chareidi educational system lacks 1000 classrooms. He praised the work of the director of the Municipal Chareidi Education Department, Rabbi Binyamin Cohen.

Rabbi Shimon Hadad said that he had merited to be one of the first students of HaRav Chaim Shaul Karelitz, zt"l. He said: "He established generations of Sephardi bnei Torah, having been inspired by the Chazon Ish, the Brisker Rav and yibodel lechayim tovim ve'arukim, Maran HaGaon HaRav Eliezer Menachem Shach, shlita. HaRav Karelitz taught us that hashkofoh issues take precedence over financial issues. In his merit, we have an illustrious community, not a community consisting of those trying to gain control of Sephardi Jewry through monopolies. A proposal has been made by these elements to start a chareidi television channel. All of us know how much damage that could cause. I bless Rabbi Ravitz and Rabbi Gafni for their efforts on behalf of the community, and ask them to denounce those who pretend to represent the Torah-loyal sector."

Rabbi Moshe Man also paid tribute to the memory of HaRav Chaim Shaul Karelitz, who was moser nefesh in his fulfillment of the wishes of Maran, the Rosh Hayeshiva. "HaRav Karelitz regarded the kashrus network of Shearis Yisroel as the most important project of his life, and we have a sacred obligation to strengthen it." He then suggested that the Degel HaTorah Knesset members hold reception hours once a month on public issues, for the benefit of Torah and educational institutions. He also said the communal representatives must present reports detailing their handling of issues discussed at previous meetings. He also mentioned the very difficult financial situation of Toda'a.

Rabbi Yaakov Gutterman, head of the Modi'in Illit Municipal Council, thanked the members of the Knesset for their efforts to secure grants and loans for those who bought apartments in Modi'in Illit, although Modi'in Illit did not appear on the Housing Ministry list of settlements eligible for such aid. He asked that the issue of "recognized, unofficial education" be raised and suggested ideas for reducing the bureaucracy plaguing the directors of the educational institutions.

The meeting was attended by the following members of the Party governing body: Yosef Abu, Aharon Agasi, Yaakov Asher, Dovid Boyer, Tzvi Baumel, Yehoshua Buchnik, Mordechai Blau, Moshe Ben-Shoshan, Yosef Becker, Yitzchok Ber, Yissochor Bergman, Dovid Breuer, Shimon Hadad, Nosson Cohen, Shmuel Epstein, Chaim Fuchs, Avraham Feiner, Yaakov Gutterman, Yehoshua Gold, Mordechai Goldberg, Shlomo Goldental, Moshe Gafni, Shmuel Grossman, Eliezer Greenbaum, Yaakov Hesse, Moshe Karp, Ben-Tziyon Kugler, Uri Kaminski, Mordechai Karelitz, Uri Lapoliansky, Moshe Lachover, Mayer Lantzman, Moshe Man, Uri Maklev, Yitzchok Neshri, Avrohom Ravitz, Avrohom Rubinstein, Yaakov Rosenstein, Yitzchok Reich, Menachem Schwartz, Moshe Shiffman, Aryeh Shtauber, Yeshayahu Smutni, Shlomo Stern, Yechiel Turgeman, Chaim Williger, Eliyahu Weinman, Yaakov Virazhbinski and Yehuda Yabrov.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.