> \
Dei'ah Vedibur - Information &
Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

2 Kislev, 5787 - November 12, 2026 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

POPULAR EDITORIALS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
chareidi.org
chareidi.org

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Opinion and Comment
Will We Lose Our Friendship With Uncle Sam?

by Rabbi Yitzchok Roth


3

The vast majority of the American public is fed up with their present president. This is not uncommon in American politics, that a president in his final term reaches a low in public opinion. Most previous presidents lost their majority support in the Senate and House of Representatives, becoming lame ducks in the second half of their term, primarily because most of the expectations pinned on them were without coverage by that time.

Trump failed to realize most of his promises to the voters, mainly on internal issues such as the economy, personal protection, health and other electoral assurances. The present president has other agendas regarding foreign relations, to make major changes on the world map like the war between Russia and the Ukraine, or Israel and the Palestinians, and surely, to win a Nobel Peace Prize. These were unrealistic dreams which shattered in the scene of reality. Trump, like his predecessors, failed in those projects, while his hope to demolish the Iranian regime also miscarried.

Now they have to find whom to blame, like the media as a whole which always resorts to the one culprit — the State of Israel. It is to blame for his plummeting in the midterm elections, no less. The selfsame president who waged the war against Iran but categorically stymied any step which could have collapsed the economic underpinnings of that country and bring it to its knees, is now looking for guilty ones, all except for him.

And thus does Israel find itself, as usual, as the blameworthy culprits, attacked by all, even by its best friend, facing the two legislative Houses, whose sympathy for it is far removed indeed. Whoever put his hopes on American support will learn the hard way that the only trust remaining for Israel is in the words of the prophet (Yeshayohu 42:24), "Who gave Yaakov for a spoil and Yisroel to the robbers? Is it not Hashem to Whom we have sinned, in Whose ways we refused to walk and to Whose Torah they were not obedient."

The Principles of the Arab Knesset Parties

Exactly twenty years ago, a supreme follow-up report of the Arab population, was drawn up and released by the Israeli Arab political parties. It was a study geared to define the place and status of the Arabs in the country.

This document, which remains relevant to this day, is signed by the chief Arab leaders of the time, including Yussuf Jabarin, today the chairman of the Joint List, the largest Arab party. Here are some paragraphs which were, and still are, among the fundamental pillars of the conception of Israeli Arabs towards the country in which they reside.

According to the authors of the document, Israel is the expression of a colonial concept which is oriented against its Arab citizens. And as such, says this document, one cannot describe Israel as a democracy but as an ethnocracy which limits the rights of the minority population residing therein. And therefore, it is obligatory that the regime here must be changed.

The change must be effected on several fronts where the Palestinian nechba (catastrophe) is recognized and steps are taken to remedy those ramifications. (The Right of Return for all Arabs, to those who fail to understand intimations.) The State must recognize Arabs as a national entity and as the original native inhabitants.

The authors of this document declare that the Palestinian Arabs in Israel are the original settlers of the land, owners of an emotional, national, religious and cultural attachment to their birthplace, and also being an inseparable part of the Palestinian Arab nation. This document calls for abolishing such concepts as "lands of the State" or "Jewish lands," and demands that no legal enforcement of present government laws of planning and construction be recognized regarding its Arab citizenry and their settlements.

After publication of this document, the Council for Peace and Security held a hearing on the matter. Among other words, one of the speakers, a national lecturer on science, stated that "in effect, it calls for the dissolution of Israel as a Zionist- Jewish state and the creation of a bi-national country, alongside a 'Yuden-Rein' Palestinian State." The Council also specified that "one cannot conceive an undermining of the right of a state to define itself as Jewish-democratic or denying its ties with world Jewry or ignoring a geographic hegemony, or territorial and national symbols which are a necessary foundation for the Judaism of the country, when such a visionary futuristic document denies all the above."

These, then, are the potential partners of the Shinui bloc, headed by Yair Golan from the far Left Democrat List, who would like to see the State as devoid of all Jewish values, a "State of its citizens," in its most simple rendition that has no trace of Jewish values. This is why he wishes to see the posse of terror supporters which regards Hamas as no more than "a national relief organization," but as a full partner in running the country on all fronts.

To Golan's dismay, the members of the Joint List are people of principles who will, under no circumstances, agree to dismantle the Jewish State even if they are guaranteed esteemed posts in the government process. At the most, they will settle for support of toppling the former government, whose sworn opposition to their nationalistic aspirations forced them to continue weaving their long-standing visions of ruling the country from within.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.