Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

15 Shevat 5771 - January 20, 2011 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

POPULAR EDITORIALS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Opinion & Comment
The Never-ending Struggle between She'eris Yisroel and Nidchei Yisroel

by HaRav Eliyahu Meir Bloch zt'l

Rosh Yeshivas Telz

It is the nature of any living and healthy organism to expel any polluted blood. This is the way the organism heals itself and protects its internal health and purity. Similarly, the Jewish Nation expels assimilators and alien influences, and in that way guards its internal purity, spirit and pristine essence as were set by the Creator.

This expulsion process can be followed, starting with the Sadducees and the Catholics and ending with the followers of the Reform and Enlightenment Movements of the past century. It applies even to those who pictured themselves—and also large sections of the nation saw in them — as being the nation's leaders and pacesetters. Healthy Judaism that is loyal to its sources, despite all the ridicule and mockery aimed at it from its opponents, continues to survive indefinitely.

They are stronger and more courageous than we are. They are the majority whereas we apparently are She'eris Yisroel, which can be misunderstood as a mere undesirable remnant of the past. By all appearances, the future belongs to them.

The truth is, however, the opposite. We are, boruch Hashem, are the She'eris Yisroel, which is truly understood as those surviving and persisting eternally. They are constantly in the midst of the process of decline and becoming extinct. They struggle within themselves about their sealed fate and are tormented with spiritual distortion, until they are expelled from Klal Yisroel. They are the true Nidchei Yisroel.

This process of expulsion pains, tortures and racks She'eris Yisroel since every Jewish neshomoh is precious to them. Also those waging war to "improve and beautify" Jewry's stature in the world, nonetheless sense they are gradually being expelled from the Jewish Nation. They and especially those coming after them, belong to the camp of future non-Jews, or even to the camp of antisemites already now.

Although they are proud of their being Modern Jews, and arrogantly regard the "backward" Jews as needing to be educated in order "to transform them into civilized people," deep down in their hearts they fear their own future. A profound struggle is taking place between their inner Jewish instinct and their specious ideologies. This instinct pecks away at their subconscious and forewarns them about the danger of spiritual destruction that their lifestyle is leading them to. This internal struggle characteristically moves them in two contrasting directions: on the one hand it intensifies their desire to fight against the truth gnawing inside their hearts, while the other hand, at least occasionally, it awakens within them reflections urging them to repent. These thoughts deter them from doing many things and force them to take steps that are in complete contradiction to their outlook on life.

Our Sages (Shevet Mussar ch. 25, Malbim Tehillim 17:2, 75:5) succinctly define this struggle and self-contradictory behavior as, "Reshoim are constantly repenting." On the other hand, as mentioned, this itself aggravates and toughens even more their open fight against true Judaism. The Novi Yeshaya (57:20) expresses the state of mind of the reshoim in the posuk, "But the reshoim will be like the driven sea that cannot rest, and whose waters disgorge mire and mud." This internal restlessness sometimes causes them to carry out abominable acts, which are a direct result from an internal conflict, of pangs of conscience.

Each person believes that "his" truth must win, and this belief awards him the power to fight and to even sacrifice himself for this truth.

We behold a process of distorted perceptions, followed by disappointments, which lead to new mistakes that soon bring further disappointment with scrambling to other mistakes, or even returning to the previous mistakes.

Culture has gone bankrupt. Consequently, they grab onto a dubious idealistic scrap that has remained and is called democracy. After they realize that the "Democratic World" doesn't concern itself with us or with justice at all, they move on and grasp communism. That ideology, however, greets them with a "fine gift" of false charges and murder. They then straightaway run to find refuge and hope in other delusions and false hopes. It is difficult to preclude all the false hopes, which are as many as the amount of our disappointments, and are as wide and deep as the sea of our misery.

The Novi (Yirmiyahu 9:2) has already foreseen this tragedy and argued: "For they go out from evil to evil, but they do not know the word of Hashem." Rashi explains: "`From evil to evil'—meaning from one sin to another." The obvious question is why does the Novi write, "they go out" when "they went" would be more appropriate? The Novi means to say that they left one aveiroh because they were disappointed from it, but that disappointment didn't lead them to the truth. Instead, it leads them to another aveiroh, to another mistake, and they still didn't realize the Divine truth.

It is difficult for a person to discern the truth when he mistakenly believes in a mistake. It is even more painful to see that when he shakes himself free from the mistake, he searches for another avodoh zorah, without even wanting to realize the truth.

"If you turn away from sin, O Yisroel, says Hashem, you will return to Me, if you remove your abominations from before Me, then you will not wander" (Yirmiyahu 4:1). If you do not want to do teshuvah and abandon your idols as long as you believe in them, I am nevertheless asking from you that, "If you turn away from sin"— if anyway you become disappointed and turn away from them—"You will return to Me"—at least turn to Me at that time. When the day will come and you "remove your abominations" it should at least be "from before Me"— in order to recognize that I am Hashem, so "you will not wander"—so you will not continue to wander from mistake to mistake.

Although extremely painful, the following question must be asked: Why do we find so few Jews returning to the truth? Why do we not see that the bitter disappointment from the idols of, "My strength and the might of my hand made me all this wealth" ( Devorim 8:17), from the different forms of assimilation either personal or national, and from "the kindness of nations is a sin" ( Mishlei 14:34), lead our nation to the truth?

The reason is that we suffer from short memory. If Jews from past generations had seen these lightning changes of history that we have experienced they would surely have recognized the real truth. In the past, changes occurred at an extremely slow pace. Two or three continuous generations could live while embracing futile illusions, and the return to the old mistakes came after one hundred or a hundred and fifty years.

However, today the various types of avodoh zorah have collapsed within a period of twenty-five to thirty years. Memory is so short that what we recognized yesterday as an ideology that we should not follow has been forgotten today. Because of this short memory, people wander and return to their past mistake.

Today we are exhausted, dejected, embarrassed and ashamed, disappointed in all the different man-created types of idols. We are wallowing in our blood, forlorn, withering and fading away. We are without any present, and the future is shrouded in gloom. Now it is for us a "time of love" (Yechezkel 16:8)! We are now prepared to hear the howling truth. Now the time has arrived about which the novi writes: "Behold days are coming—the word of the Lord Hashem Elokim when I will send hunger into the land; not a hunger for bread nor a thirst for water, but to hear the words of Hashem" ( Amos 8:11). That time will be the final end for the different types of avodoh zorah, and the idols of Don and Beer Sheva (see Amos 7:5) will fall and not rise again.

The yahrtzeit of HaRav Block zt"l was 28 Teves.


All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.