Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

16 Shevat 5765 - January 26, 2005 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Opinion & Comment
On Banners and Bugles

by Yochonon Dovid

Someone with sensitive vision can discern when a black flag flutters over a particular sin, with blinking warning red lights. This is when the surrounding causes of that sin augment its severity a thousandfold. The Yetzer Tov warns and pleads: You are jeopardizing your entire future world in one moment. Flee for your life!

And there are those commandments which appear to be innocently routine, but anyone who has developed finely tuned sensors can feel and see where and when those factors increase the commandment to mighty dimensions of very far- reaching implications and consequences.

*

We were given 613 commandments in the Torah. Everyone — even if he is no scholar — knows that they are not equal in importance, severity or require absolute compliance at all times and under all circumstances. Some commandments are categorized as "yeihoreg ve'al ya'avor — die rather than transgress," while others are laid aside for lifesaving reasons. Prohibitive commandments must be honored at any price, while there are some positive commandments that one is absolved from keeping if they require extreme outlay beyond a certain limit.

Halacha deals at length with the clarification of conflict between two commandments. Which supersedes which? There are many indications to hint to us the degree of a mitzva's severity. We also find a reward label attached to certain commandments in the Torah or punishment decreed for transgressing certain prohibitive commandments, both indicating the status of that commandment.

Mitzvos differ from one another in many details, such as: Upon whom are they incumbent? When must they be performed? Constantly? Once daily? Once yearly? Only under certain circumstances — and so on.

Then there is the venue of their obligation: Commandments dependent upon living in Eretz Yisroel. And despite all this, we have never heard of anyone who actually made a chart analyzing the whole list of commandments and dividing them by a rising or falling degree of their importance.

We will attempt here to point to certain factors that are outside the actual body of the commandment but whose presence can change its size and importance, be they positive or prohibitive, in a very polar way.

Eating a kezayis of treif meat is a severe sin which contaminates the soul of the transgressor, as is written in the Torah. Despite its stringency, this sin remains within the realm of the transgressor alone. But a buyer for a hotel or for a wedding hall who buys meat and chicken from a dubious source because of its lower price is deceiving the public and causing it to sin unwittingly, and his sins are compounded by the thousands, even if he, himself, is a vegetarian.

Sometimes, a person is asked about the kashrus of a certain place and he replies without thinking twice, very offhand, that he believes it to be completely kosher on a high standard, for he once saw the son of the owner several years ago, and he seemed `quite up to our standards,' i.e., `one of us.' If that establishment is not really up to par, then the informer is (dis)credited with all those who subsequently rely on his report and eat forbidden food. How foolhardy and stupid it was of that person to so blithely endanger his soul just so that someone can make a profit, or to posture as a know-it-all who always has the needed information at his fingertips.

The entry of a tomei meis, one who is impure for having come in contact with the dead, to the Har Habayis was explicitly forbidden by the Torah under punishment of koreis. There was once a philanthropist from abroad who visited Eretz Yisroel and joined a tour of Har Habayis. A well known rabbi wrote to him and informed him that all of his charitable activities over many years for the sake of the Yishuv, and the millions that he donated, did not outweigh the severe transgression of his one-time entering the forbidden area of Har Habayis in an impure state.

Try now to imagine the blameworthiness of the tourist bureau, the tour guide who arranged the visits for large groups which certainly included Jews, and all those who aided and abetted that act, even if they sported a kippah on their head and bore a deep love for Eretz Yisroel, and the mountain of terrible sins which they bore upon their records for having caused so many to sin.

A century or so ago, a Maskil wrote his thoughts in a book that gained wide distribution. His chances of ever completing his term of punishment in the World of Truth are absolutely nil. Whenever the book is sold out and no longer available, there are people who are quick to reprint a new edition and disseminate it to students and the general public, generation after generation. All the adverse effects of his heresy are tacked on to his record and this is very, very long. The sins of his impact increase and multiply in a wide ripple effect. Every sin committed by anyone who was influenced by his teachings, and the sins of his children and grandchildren that ensue as well for generations to follow, are all registered to his name. Every shehakol blessing overlooked, every commandment transgressed or ignored, is all recorded. Every bittul Torah, every four cubits walked without proper headcovering and myriad sins are unloaded frequently at the depot of that heretical writer, whose fire in Gehennom will never be doused.

Similarly, one who speaks loshon hora is liable to find himself in the same situation. He says his evil slander to several people. The tale is true but the Torah forbids him from spreading it. His audience carries that tale to others — neighbors, relatives, friends and acquaintances. And these do likewise. A simple calculation shows that such a story, progressing from mouth to mouth, can encompass a city of one hundred thousand people in mere days. And even if the first tale bearer regrets his sin, he will no longer be able to erase its effect and the ramifications thereof from the minds of the hearers. The dangerous germ which he released into the atmosphere has multiplied and increased, and is disseminating its poison in all of its details, and these are accredited to the account of the original tale-bearer, which grows and inflates itself from day-to-day to huge proportions.

Someone once broadly interpreted the words of our prayer, "And `plant us' [vesito'einu — which can also stem from the root `to err'] within our boundaries" as follows: "Hashem, even if we err, please see to it that these errors do not outstep their bounds." For example if, many years ago, a person stated that he treated burns successfully by smearing oil, and to this day causes burn victims untold pain and suffering because of his harmful advice, it is difficult to erase the mistaken information from people's minds, and he is to be held responsible, to some extent, for all that suffering.

Kiddush Hashem is a mighty and powerful commandment. Tens of thousands of Jews have sacrificed their lives for Hashem's Name over the ages. On the other hand, today, many people who sanctify Hashem's Name are alive to tell the story. Their Kiddush Hashem is an ongoing act of honesty, truth, exemplary character, kindness etc. They radiate goodness and are shining examples of superior human beings to all who come in contact with them, Jews and gentiles alike, even heretics. These people were not burned at any stake in the public square of some Christian country in Europe with the cry of Shema Yisroel upon their lips. And yet, they are listed alongside those very martyrs who did die sacrificing their lives for Hashem's sake. For their very lives are a sanctification of Hashem, a glorification of His Name. Every simple act of theirs highlights the Divine image of Hashem in which they were created.

Chillul Hashem is a terrible sin. One who desecrates His Name creates a void in the world or in the minds of men and shucks off the sanctity of Hashem which fills the entire earth. He creates a lacuna, a vacuum of the reality of the glory of Hashem and His holiness. This is the complete opposite of the condition which we strive to maintain and which we pray shall be augmented in this world: "We wish for You, Hashem our G-d, to speedily see the glory of Your might . . . that all flesh and blood call upon Your Name . . . To You shall all knees be prostrated . . . and to the glory of Your Name shall tribute be given . . . And He shall let us hear, again, in the presence of all living creatures `to be unto you a G-d.' "

Whoever desecrates Hashem's Name is not only that `rabbi' who converted to Christianity in a flourishing ceremony in the Vatican in Rome. Take the politician interviewed by the media who throws in some phrases in crass language, blaspheming Hashem and His Messiah and those who study His Torah, and forthwith — he is inscribed in the Book of the Wicked who desecrate Hashem's Name in public. Those words were said at a supper in his home and he deserves to be punished stringently for them, but since tens of thousands were listening to him in the media, and the headlines testified to it in the following morning papers, his blasphemous words carried so much more weight that he is forever doomed and he has lost his portion in Olom Habo.

One with finely attuned sight can sense when a particular sin has a black flag waving over it and flickering warning red lights above it. This is when the circumstances of that sin accentuate its severity a thousand and millionfold. The yetzer hatov will plead and warn him: You are endangering your whole world in one split moment! Flee for your life!

And then, there are some mitzvos which appear routine, ordinary, but one who has developed fine tuning will feel and see where and when the particular circumstances increase that mitzva to huge proportions with very far-reaching ramifications. (A neighbor advises how to clean a garment from tar stains and incidentally, asks: Which kindergarten do you recommend for my daughter?)

Fortunate is the one who hears those bugles trumpeting the opportunity of gaining an eternal treasure!


All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.