Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

20 Teves 5763 - December 25, 2002 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family


LETTERS, EITZES, FEEDBACK

Re: The Grant

[A story written as a result of a mother's struggle to enroll her CP son of normal intelligence into a standard yeshiva. Parshiyos Miketz-Vayigash]

When I started looking last spring for a first grade class for my Down's syndrome daughter, Rina, I was hoping to mainstream her into a normal school with the help of a one-on- one teacher's aide, called a sayaat. I know that in England, some 60% of first graders with Down's syndrome are mainstreamed and numerous studies have shown the inclusion to be both cheaper and better for these students than special ed. In our case, the helper would be paid 12 hours weekly by the Ministry of Education and the city, and the rest by me.

I tried every chareidi school in Bnei Brak (except for those with loshon kodesh Ashkenazic pronunciation since I didn't want to confuse her); they all turned us down. None of them bothered to contact the professionals who work with Rina or even her kindergarten teacher.

The reasons were varied: "Our classes are too big (the only valid excuse I heard); our teachers don't want to work with an aide; I'd like to get rid of my wheelchair student, but can't (I flipped at that one!); you're Ashkenazic and we're Sefardi; you live too far -- she'll come tired (a ten minute drive); or another version -- you live too far and maybe she'll come late; parents will protest; you're not from our area so why should I deal with you?; we think it's stupid of you to want to integrate/mainstream her into a regular class (shiluv); we already have a 3rd grade special class in our school; we took in a special student already this year; our first grade classes are on the third floor and we can't move a first grade class to the ground floor to be near the special ed class (this is not necessary as Rina climbs stairs great)" and finally, "We've never done this before."

As it stands now, Rina is still at home. Actually, I pay a teacher's aide three hours daily to study with Rina. She is already reading stories of short sentences complete with vowels.

The only place the city can offer me is a special coeducational class in a Mizrachi school, which is not what I want. It is very difficult and painful to believe that with all the chareidi first grades in Bnei Brak, none can accept my daughter and because of the stalling and inaction which has resulted in her not starting school -- even the twelve hours we are entitled to by the Ministry of Education have been taken away from us. In the event that I do find a school willing to take her, I will have to pay an additional 1,000 shekel for her tuition.

We cannot help being disillusioned by the frum community and those Jews in key positions who could have helped us but didn't, and stalled and even lied to us. We still pray that our yeshua is still somewhere around the corner, of Rechov Chazon Ish or Rabbi Akiva or anywhere in Bnei Brak.

Is there anyone influential out there willing to go to bat for us?

Ruth Palatnik, Rechov Bartenura 4, 03-579-4996.

Ed. Why don't you tell it all to the Hebrew Yated's Kav Hacham? Maybe they can get results for you.

ANOTHER ASHER YOTZAR MIRACLE

It was several years ago that your editor printed a miracle story I heard firsthand involving the asher yotzar blessing. It told of an incontinent, non- communicating autistic boy of six who was suddenly able to control his excretions and who began to talk -- overnight, after his father resolved to distribute Asher Yotzar placards in his city. Father and son joined us at our Shabbos table upon a visit to Eretz Yisroel.

My family heard the story and internalized its message.

This past week, my granddaughter developed a very painful sore on her lip. When it blew up the following morning, she went to the doctor who gave her a salve. The sore got much worse and became so painful that she was reduced to taking painkillers every two hours with little relief.

She tried the conventional remedies of black salve [a great addition to any medicine chest, called ichtyol, for infected fingers and the like -- belongs in the EITZES section] and asked a neighbor what she advised. (She didn't...)

Her mother sent her to the doctor again and this time, he prescribed antibiotics. "It's too deep to lance," he said. The antibiotics didn't help and the girl was in such tremendous agony that she couldn't... oh, do anything, even lie down.

Then she remembered the cure-all for bodily ailments. Saying Asher Yotzar with as much kavona as one can muster. In her condition, it was not difficult; she was appealing to the Master Healer, the last Resort.

The next time she had to say this blessing, she uttered every single word with deep concentration and was emotionally exhausted by the time she had finished. And just then, the neighbor knocked.

"I was looking around in my medicine chest and found some vitamin E. It can't hurt to smear some on. Who knows? It might even help."

Lo and behold! Within minutes the infection burst and pus came streaming out. There was instant relief and from there on it was a question of a natural process of recovery.

"It was the `nekovim nekovim' that did it," says my granddaughter. "Hashem made an opening so that the pus could come out."

EPILOGUE ON EPIDURAL

The controversy rages on and I think we will close it. Anyone who still wishes to pursue this vital topic is welcome to call me and get the numbers of this present writer, as well as the one quoted in a recent Letter:

I was grateful to see an article finally informing chareidi women of the risks and dangers involved in what have become almost `routine' epidurals (Nov. 22). It is vital that information such as that which was provided in Esther Marilus' article be brought to the attention of all child- bearing women.

However, a week ago, a small "Letter..." appeared as a disclaimer, disagreeing with the facts, though providing no source material to support that disclaimer. In fact, the midwife with "many years of experience" even claimed that women suffer post-partum depression as a result of being made to endure the `pain and suffering' of natural childbirth! [Ed. Some women do...]

This feeds right into the system of fear that promotes women's willingness to subject themselves to drugs that are not without risk! Why are we helping create a `need' for medicated birth when women could instead be educated to have healthy, normal births without analgesics and epidurals?

The reasons for post-partum depression are vast and complicated... one cause being the distressingly bad HOSPITAL experiences women are made to endure, where they are not allowed to move around, are placed in uncomfortable positions, do not receive the emotional support they need, are made to feel at the mercy of medical decisions and `recommendations' and are even YELLED at if they don't `cooperate.' What I found most distasteful about the anonymous letter was the implication that without chemical relief, childirth is a time of `pain and suffering' that can leave a woman permanently traumatized!

Where is our emuna in Hashem? Where is our understanding of how He actually created us in a uniquely marvelous way, perfectly designed for bringing new Yiddishe neshomos into the world? The belief in our own bodies' Heavenly granted strength should be instilled in every kalla before her wedding. Hashem didn't make a mistake in designing us. In fact, our own bodies actually produce natural chemicals with opiate-like qualities to help us cope with pain!

Expecting women need encouragement and support, not demeaning, undermining messages of "Poor dear, we know you can't manage without some form of pain relief." With the proper emotional, Hashkafic, physiological and psychological preparation, our community should be raising girls to LOOK FORWARD to the unique, miraculous experience of childbirth that can be ours. Childbirth can be a truly uplifting, exhilirating experience that more deeply bonds women to their babies and to Hashem. The impact of having a positive experience can affect the relationship of a mother to her child for life.

Maybe it is time for our community to reclaim that which our foremothers -- and prototype midwives like Shifra and Pua of this week's parsha -- knew intuitively: that birth is an intimate process between us and Hashem as we joined Him in a celebration of Creation. It seems that our generation sorely needs positive reinforcement to remind us of the wisdom with which we were created!

A concerned mother of many (Name Withheld)

EITZES

Lots of Lox

R.P. told me this one. It belongs in the cooking section but is so incredible that we'll just include it here this time.

Take a piece of salmon fillet. Cover it with thick salt, place in a plastic bag overnight in the refrigerator. Rinse off well the following day.

Voila -- delicious lox, believe it or nox.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.