Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

17 Adar I 5760 - February 23, 2000 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Sponsored by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Produced and housed by
Jencom

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family
The Bas Mitzva Issue

We would like to deal with the question of Bas Mitzva from three aspects and ask for readers' comments for coming issues.

LAST WEEK I had the privilege of attending my granddaughter's class Bas Mitzva celebration. It was three hours of pure spiritual elevation, nachas and nachas ruach. Held in an auditorium, it was a wonderful experience in which some 200 Bais Yaakov future mothers and their mothers/grandmothers celebrated their coming of age and accepting, so graciously, their new yoke of mitzvos. There was a beautiful choir which sang original songs with a very thought-provoking message, made a presentation, and listened to messages from teachers that, if not remembered verbatim, will remain in their hearts and subconscious memories for the years to come.

My granddaughter will not be twelve for another four months, but it makes no difference. When her birthday comes around, she will be ready for her new role, BE'H: to be a good Jewish daughter and make her people proud. She will have no need for lavish celebrations of mountains of food and gifts and a great to-do. It will come quietly, modestly, aristocratically.

LAST MONTH I had an article submitted to the paper on Bas Mitzva celebrations for the home. I prepared it for publication since I felt that as some people were going to celebrate this event, anyway, why not give it the right touch<196>to do so in the home, keep the externals to a minimum, to downplay the material aspects and play up the positive, spiritual significance of the event.

The paper rejected the article. This was not the Yated line, not its outlook. Being three weeks wiser now and one REAL Bas Mitzva celebration more experienced, I thoroughly concur with that decision, as I really had to begin with. Perhaps I needed the contrast between the two presentations to get my bearings straight.

Which brings us to a letter and article I found in my mailbox this morning from a reader in Betar:

DEAR EDITOR,

In the 21 Shevat edition, you requested material from amateurs, so here it is. I would love comments. [To our readers, the following is not amateurish in the least, and we, too, would like your impressions and comments.]

As you can see from the enclosed letter, my non-frum niece is `making' her Bas Mitzva. Although my daughters did not obviously have any public demonstration when they were Bas Mitzva [I gather she excludes a school celebration], nor did I or they feel a lack, I wanted to try to find the merit in my niece's situation. I am worried that my not stating our outlook about Bas Mitzva might cause my niece confusion, but I feel that the need to make a positiive connection outweighs the risk. She is going to have it anyway, so I can at least be `there' if/when she is ready to question. The lines will be open.

It would be nice to see a discussion in the paper of how to keep lines open to our non-religious friends, relatives and neighbors. Thanks for the interesting articles in the Family section. It's always the first thing I read when I get the paper. [Thanks to you, B.K. Now you're part of it, too.]

Dear Heather Michelle (Yeta Merigolda),

Although the world is getting smaller, communication- wise, we are still quite far from each other. With the celebration of your Bas Mitzva coming up, we feel it even more so. Growing up, I always had an ideal of what a great- aunt should be (a compilation of all my aunts, I guess), and yet, I don't think I have fulfilled even my first criterium, to know you, my niece. As you know, we live very different lives, being religious, living in Eretz Yisroel, having such a large family (at least by American standards) and so on. I'm always afraid that you look at us as aliens, so unfamiliar to your life. Yet at this point in time, when you are now accepting the yoke of your heritage, I feel a need to reconnect and let you know who we are and to know more about you.

The teen-age years are exciting, turbulent, confusing and filled with growing self-awareness. In the orthodox world, girls are Bas-Mitzva-ed at twelve. The Torah says they are more mature than boys, as you have probably noticed already. In this year, not only does your body change, but also your outlook on life; your own self image is also being redefined. This is a time in your life when you begin to choose your own goals and ambitions. These are important years.

It's not like you are playing house like a child and just role-modeling what you saw being done by the adults around you. You are now setting up the foundations of what you will really be as an adult. You are now learning the skills of work, friendships and other ideals. In these times you will test previous conceptions and find new ones. The values and ethical principles that your parents have given you are your strengths and goal posts. Your Bat Mitzva is the beginning of recognizing these goals posts, the Jewish outlook of life, and making it part of your being.

I know you probably think that because we are Orthodox, our lives are difficult with so many rules to follow. But we think the opposite. Growing up in a non-Jewish environment, you have to be very strong to maintain your difference and recognize what your heritage is, as opposed to that of your Christian neighbors. Your choice to make a public declaration of your Bas Mitzva has shown your pride in being a Jew and has set you apart and above mundane matters. You are part of a proud nation. You are like a princess among civilians, and as part of the royal family, you have different rules. More is expected of you. The world judges you by different standards. Your Bas Mitzva means that you need to live by higher expectations.

You have probably heard this story before; it is family tradition. You and your cousin, Yocheved Merigolda, are named after the same ancestress, your great-great-grandmother Merigolda. She came to America as a young girl without parents; only an older brother accompanied her.

In those days, everyone worked seven days a week. No one took Shabbos off, for it entailed being fired from work week to work week. Merigolda found a job at a garment factory, like most Jewish women in those days. It was called the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory. When her brother found out that she would have to work seven days a week, he was horrified.

"How can you work on Shabbos? What would Mother think?" Merigolda couldn't reconcile her mother's disappointment and quit. A week later, the factory had a disastrous fire in which one hundred and forty-six women were killed. It changed history, for building codes, labor laws and the power of labor unions were changed forever after. In the merit of Shabbos and honoring her mother, Merigolda's life was saved and you were able to come about. You see, we think WE keep Shabbos, but it is really Shabbos that keeps US.

Among the music, gifts and guests, I am sure that you will realize the solemnity of this occasion. We just wanted you to know that we are proud of you, love and miss you.

MAZEL TOV.

Love,

Your aunt.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.