Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

19 Iyar 5759, May 5 1999 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family
Time to Stand on Their Own Feet
by R. Gil

Many children continue to be financially dependent upon their parents long after the wedding. Some receive an ongoing supply of benefits or allowances. Some couples take their main meal by their parents for the entire first year after marriage, while others are constant Shabbos guests. Most parents are in long-term debt from marrying off their children, either to revolving gemachim or through mortgages. Has the time not arrived for children to open their eyes, to sharpen their senses and to ask themselves if they have not become a burden to their parents?

I met Shevi, who lives on the border of Bnei Brak-Ramat Gan, at a shopping center one day. She looked carefree and lighthearted as she was choosing a child's outfit whose price tag was in the several hundreds. She wrote out a check without batting an eyelid and seemed pleased with her purchase.

"I always buy expensive clothing. The price tells me it's high quality that will last," she boasts.

"At that rate, you can go bankrupt," I couldn't help noting. "You need a full time salary just for clothing alone."

"My father pays for it," she said unabashed.

So this was the secret of her equanimity. It was not her husband's kollel check she was spending, but her father's bank account that was underwriting her standard of living. "I work in my father's office," she continued to confide, "but really, only when I feel up to it. I have no regular hours." Shevi is registered on the payroll and can afford a weekly ozeret.

I was shocked, and couldn't help showing it. She seemed very comfortable with her lifestyle and felt no need to make any changes, she admitted freely, in reply to the questions I couldn't help asking.

"My father has plenty," she said with a dismissing wave of her hand. "He loves to give us."

This is an extreme case of a businessman with three children who does not feel any pinch in providing for his daughter's generous standard of living. With most families, this is not the case. Parents are deep in debt, but continue to provide for their married children, be it with a steady flow of groceries right to their doorstep, allowances, free lunches, fish for Shabbos, and so on, long after the wedding.

Kest, or provision for young couples for a certain specified time after their marriage, has long been a Jewish institution, especially for bnei Torah devoting this period to Torah study. But the situation has changed, at least in Eretz Yisroel, where in most cases, children are provided with an apartment as they start off their married life, which sets parents in debt for many years to come, and where the husband receives a living stipend from whatever kollel he attends.

Shuli receives a meat order delivered every other week to her doorstep. She has no conscience pangs about accepting it; after all, her mother holds two jobs and earns a good salary. So why not?

Shuly's mother did not want her to feel any different from her married classmates who eat their main meal by their parents every day. But being out of the house most of the day made it very difficult for her. For the week after sheva brochos, she took time off from work to be home and serve three course meals, but soon saw that she would be unable to keep it up. She `compromised' by providing the meat necessary for Shuli to cook. A `concession' on her part.

In my pursuit to answers to the questions of how much do parents provide, I came across a young kollel wife, married a year with a child, who does not feel the need to go out to work even though her father can barely support his family and cover the basic utilities. "I know that they won't let me starve," she says with a shrug, and continues to accept a weekly fruit order delivered to her doorstep.

To the credit of married children who continue to take/accept help from parents is the good will in which the help is extended. "More than the calf wishes to nurse does the cow wish to suckle." They don't realize how difficult it can be for the parents and truly think that this is the parents' greatest pleasure in life. "If they didn't have, they wouldn't give." "They don't feel any lack" are only some of the reactions we received. But this is not always true, and in their naivete, children fail to realize it.

One interesting point was raised in our inquiries: "They've accustomed us to taking" and "If they had not begun, we would not have dreamed of asking..." In other words, married children who continue to receive fish/meat for Shabbos `blame' the parents for this, for having clipped their wings, so to speak, and made them reliant upon their generosity. It becomes a pattern no one will break.

A mother of two married children explains why she continues to serve hot meals daily to her married daughter and son-in- law: "It is a burden with a price to pay and I personally don't think it justified. She already has her own home and even though she doesn't have enough practical cooking skills and confidence in herself, it's time she began acquiring them. But her friends go to their parents' for meals and I don't want her to feel she is any different. I wish someone would open her eyes to the other side of the situation. I guess this goes for the general public, as well. It's time we all woke up to the reality of how difficult it is to keep on pampering our married children and to change some of the accepted social norms."

This, then, is the point of this piece. If parents are able to give and take satisfaction in doing so -- all the credit to them. But when the giving is a great effort and not justified in real terms, children should become sensitized and have the courage to refuse. They should not wait until the parents are forced to say so themselves. Let them thank their parents for their help up till now, and begin to rely on their own resources, and cut down standards, if that is what is called for.

The satisfaction that the young couples will feel in standing independently on their own two feet will be well worth any sacrifice on their part.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.